top of page

Subscribe to our newsletter • Don’t miss out!

Painted illustration for How Should Christians Respond After a Saint Nicholas Relic Was Destroyed in a French Basilica? - an old stone basilica in soft winter light with a tall tower and candles glowing in its windows - Boundless at boundlessonlinechurch.org

How Should Christians Respond After a Saint Nicholas Relic Was Destroyed in a French Basilica?

Nov 10
3 min read

Photo: an old stone basilica in soft winter light with a tall tower and candles glowing in its windows

By Dr. Layne McDonald

Christians respond to this loss by grieving an attack on a place of prayer, telling the story truthfully, and refusing to answer contempt with contempt. A fragment tied to Saint Nicholas was taken and reportedly destroyed in France. Our hope was never in bone or stone, and our grief is still real tonight.

Painted illustration for How Should Christians Respond After a Saint Nicholas Relic Was Destroyed in a French Basilica? - a quiet chapel interior with rows of lit candles before a statue - Boundless at boundlessonlinechurch.org
Rows of Small Flames — © Boundless Online Church / FA Memphis — www.boundlessonlinechurch.org

What happened

Bone fragments attributed to Saint Nicholas, the fourth-century bishop of Myra and the man behind the Santa Claus story, were stolen from the Basilica of Saint-Nicolas-de-Port in Lorraine, in northeastern France, before allegedly being burned and crushed, Brussels Signal reported. The parish priest filed an official complaint on November 2, reporting that a reliquary holding the fragments had been taken. Reports differ on the exact day of the theft itself.

Police identified and arrested a suspect at his home. The man, who has not been named, reportedly admitted breaking the display case, then burning and crushing the relic, saying he acted from a desire to destroy it and viewed devotion to it as a form of idol worship, according to regional reporting. Parish priests said the investigation made it possible to identify and arrest him, and that he admitted the acts. A heritage group for the basilica said on November 7 that the church's main relic of the saint, kept in an arm-shaped holder in the treasury, was not harmed. The Interior Ministry recorded 848 anti-Christian acts in France in 2025, up 9 percent from the year before, the report said.

What does the Bible say?

Christians of different traditions hold different views about relics, and this post respects that. What every Christian shares is this: the Church's treasure was never an object. Saint Nicholas himself is remembered for secret gifts to the poor and for standing firm for the true faith in a hard century. Second Corinthians chapter 4 says we hold God's treasure in jars of clay, so that the surpassing power belongs to God and not to us. A broken case in a basilica cannot break that treasure, and no fire can burn the name of Jesus out of France.

At the same time, grief is right. Nehemiah wept when he heard Jerusalem's walls were broken, and his grief became prayer, then work. The basilica's people will hold their torchlight procession on December 5, the evening before the saint's feast day on December 6, and that is a picture of the church in every age: we carry light through the street anyway. Our response to contempt is not contempt back. Romans chapter 12 says do not be overcome by evil, but overcome evil with good.

Painted illustration for How Should Christians Respond After a Saint Nicholas Relic Was Destroyed in a French Basilica? - an ancient stone church door with a wreath in early winter light - Boundless at boundlessonlinechurch.org
The Wreath on the Old Door — © Boundless Online Church / FA Memphis — www.boundlessonlinechurch.org

How does a Christian go about this?

Put it into practice

  • Pray for the basilica's parish and town by name tonight

  • Tell the story only with facts the reports support

  • Thank God Nicholas is remembered for giving to the poor

  • Give secretly to someone in need this week, in his spirit

  • Refuse mocking words about other Christians' traditions

  • Pray for the suspect to meet the mercy of Christ

Carry this with you

Long before he was a face on wrapping paper, Nicholas was a bishop who gave gold in the night so three sisters would not be sold, and who loved the poor when it cost him. If this story stirs you, do one quiet act of secret giving this week and pray for a little basilica in Lorraine getting ready to carry its candles through the dark. Come share that story with us at Boundless; this is what a church family is for.

Painted illustration for How Should Christians Respond After a Saint Nicholas Relic Was Destroyed in a French Basilica? - a torchlight procession moving through an old town street at dusk - Boundless at boundlessonlinechurch.org
Torches Through the Old Town — © Boundless Online Church / FA Memphis — www.boundlessonlinechurch.org

Questions people ask

Do all Christians honor relics the same way?

No. Traditions differ, and many evangelical Christians do not venerate relics at all. What unites Christians here is simpler: an attack on a house of prayer is worth grieving, the facts should be told carefully, and the man responsible should be prayed for, not hated.

Who was the real Saint Nicholas?

He was a fourth-century bishop of Myra, remembered for courage under persecution and for secret generosity to the poor, including the famous gift that saved three sisters from being sold. His feast day is December 6, and his giving is the root of the Santa Claus story.

Need prayer right now? Text 1-901-213-7341 and someone will pray with you. Boundless is an online church family for people who cannot get to a building. You can belong here, and we will help you find a local Assemblies of God church near you. Visit boundlessonlinechurch.org.

Comments


bottom of page